| Name | Position | Honor(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Tremell Adams | G | 2010 NJCAA Division II 1st Team All-American, NJCAA All-Star |
| Nick Carey | G | 2009 NJCAA Division II 1st Team All-American, Region IV- A All Region 1st team, Region IV-A All Tournament Team |
| DeAngelo McIntosh | F | 2009 Division II Region IV-A All-Region First Team |
| Bradley Birton | F | 2009 Region IV-A All Region 2nd Team, Tournament MVP |
| Larry Swann | G | 2008 Division II Region IV-A Tournament MVP |
| Billy Rush | G | 2008 Division II Region IV-A All-Region First Team |
| A.J. Mandani | G | 2008 Division II Region IV-A All-Tournament Team |
| Elijah Muhammad Cunningham | G | 2008 NJCAA Division II National Tournament All-Tournament Team |
| Kris Harris | G | 2007 First Team All-American; 2007 NJCAA Division II National Tournament All-Tournament Team; 2007 Region IV-A Tournament MVP |
| Larry Swann | G | 2007 Region IV Division II-A All-Tournament Team |
| Donovan O'Neil | F | 2006 Region IV Division II-A All-Region Second Team |
| LeMar Phillips | 2003 Region IV Division I All-Region Basketball Team | |
| Dewayne Shaw | 2002 Region IV Division I All-Region Basketball Team |